More than one in five construction contractors believe written health and safety policies frequently differ from actual working practices, according to new research from Veriforce CHAS.
The “Closing the construction compliance gap” report surveyed 500 construction contractors aged 18 to 70, revealing differences between documented safety procedures and their implementation on site.
Despite these concerns, 90% of respondents rated overall health and safety standards within the construction industry as excellent or good.
Safety policies not always reflected on site
The research found that 22% of contractors believe written safety policies often or very often differ from what happens during everyday construction activities.
Respondents identified several barriers preventing organisations from meeting safety requirements consistently.
A lack of enforcement on site was the most frequently cited challenge, identified by 26% of contractors.
Insufficient training and competence followed at 25%, while 24% highlighted poor communication on site.
Near miss reporting shows mixed progress
The findings also revealed contrasting experiences of near miss reporting across construction workplaces.
While 39% of contractors said near misses are reported more frequently than five years ago, 31% reported a decline.
These findings suggest that reporting practices vary across the sector, despite broader recognition of workplace safety requirements.
Competence verification remains inconsistent
The report found that only 45% of contractors are typically required to provide evidence of their competence, qualifications or training before beginning work.
By comparison, 57% are required to submit health and safety policies and procedures.
This difference highlights a potential gap between documenting safety arrangements and verifying the capabilities of workers undertaking construction activities.
Building Safety Act influences competence requirements
The research also identified changes in how construction businesses demonstrate workforce competence.
Some 84% of respondents said the Building Safety Act 2022 and subsequent Building Regulations changes have affected their organisation’s approach to demonstrating competence.
This includes greater emphasis on providing evidence of relevant skills, experience, qualifications and training.
The findings highlight the continuing importance of effective enforcement, communication and competence verification in translating written safety policies into consistent working practices.
Ari Fatah, Technical Standards Manager at VeriforceCHAS, said: “Where near misses go unreported, organisations can appear to have a positive safety record when the reality of onsite safety could be very different.
“On busy construction sites with moving vehicles, heavy equipment and multiple professions, reporting a near-miss can feel like reporting a non-incident. But failing to report them can allow unsafe practices to continue – effectively putting everyone onsite at risk.
“By encouraging a proactive safety culture, where there’s clear communication around health and safety and on-site enforcement, workers can feel confident raising near-miss and safety concerns.
“This means we’re able to identify areas for improvement and put controls in place before they lead to injuries or serious accidents.”
“Anyone carrying out or managing building work must have the appropriate skills, knowledge, experience and behaviours for their role, while those appointing them must take reasonable steps to ensure they are competent.
“Failing to properly demonstrate and verify competence can create significant regulatory, operational and reputational risk.
“Independent verification and industry recognised certifications, such as Safety Schemes in Procurement (SSIP) and Common Assessment Standard (CAS), give a consistent baseline for assessing contractor competence and help drive higher standard across the industry.”